(35)Jens Erik Skydsgaard,Review of The Ancient Economy by M.I.Finley,Technology and Culture,pp.617-619. (36)Peter E.Gunther,Review of The Ancient Economy by M.I.Finley,The Canadian Journal of Economics/Revue canadienne d'Economique,Vol.7,No.3(Aug.,1974),pp.530-531. (37)Ian Morris,pp.xxiii-xxxi. (38)诚如普勒克特指出的,正是在芬利模式的激发下,古史学家们才开始进一步深入研究其它模式体系下的“非农业分支”(non-agrarian branches)。因此,古史学家应该向芬利表达敬意。H.W.Pleket,Review of Trade and Famine in Classical Antiquity by Peter Garnsey,C.R.Whittaker,Gnomon,57.Bd.,H.2(1985),pp.148-154. (39)Peter Garnsey,Keith Hopkins,and C.R.Whittaker eds.,Trade in Ancient Economy,University of California Press,1983. (40)为什么必须对芬利的观点进行修正呢?霍普金斯在《古代经济中的贸易》一书的介绍中做出了有关这一问题的社会学角度的解释。Keith Hopkins,"Introduction," Trade in Ancient Economy,pp.xi-xii. (41)Giuseppe Pucci,"Pottery and Trade in Roman Period",Trade in Ancient Economy,pp.105-117. (42)André Tchernia,"Italian Wine in Gual at the End of the Republic",Trade in Ancient Economy,pp.87-104. (43)H.W.Pleket,"Urban Elites and Business in the Greece Part of the Roman Empire",Trade in Ancient Economy,pp,131-144. (44)关于学界对“oikos争论”的情况由来已久,相关论述可见Finley,The Ancient Economy,chapt.1,1985; M.Nafissi,'Marx's Paradox and Weber's Solution:the Foundations of Athenian Democracy',Journal of Max Weber Studies 1.1(2000).pp.56-83; Bradley A.Ault,"Oikos and Oikonomia:Greek Houses,Households and the Domestic Economy",British School at Athens Studies,Vol.15,BUILDING COMMUNITIES:House,Settlement and Society in the Aegean and Beyond(2007),pp.259-265;较新的成果可见Hans Derks,"A Fascinating Oikos",Chapt.1 from The Oikos versus the Market(forthcoming 2013).http://www.hderks.dds.nl/discussions.html#Ancient_Economy. (45)Hans Derks,Stad en Land,Markt en Oikos,Amsterdam:Un.of Amsterdam,1986. (46)E.Coben,Athenian Economy and Society:A Banking Perspective.科恩的《雅典人的经济与社会》一书从一个新的视角向芬利正统发出挑战,科恩因此而获得1993年美国历史协会赫尔伯特·费斯奖。 (47)Inn Morris,pp.xxiii-xxxi. (48)Walter Scheidel,Sitta von Reden eds.,The Ancient Economy,Edinburgh:Edinburgh University Press,2002. (49)笔者曾就“芬利模式”问题请教了汉斯·德克斯先生,他慷慨赠文,并作了耐心细致的答复,谨此致谢。Hans Derk,The "Ancient Economy":The Problem and the Fraud,The European Legacy,7(2002),p.701-735. (50)W.Scheidel,I.Morris,R.Sailer,The Cambridge Economic History of the Greco-Roman World,Cambridge University Press,2007. (51)R.Osborne,Archaic Greece; P.R.Bedford,The Persian Neat East; R.van der Speck,The Hellenistic Near East; D.W.Rathbone,Roman Egypt; B.W.Frier & P.Kohoe,Law and Economic Institutions in The Cambridge Economic History of the Greco-Roman World,Cambridge University Press,2007. (52)Peter Fibiger Bang,Thirty Years After Finley,Review of The Ancient Economy by W.Scheidel,S.von Reden,The Classical Review,New Series,Vol.53,No.1(Apr.,2003),pp.151-153.
(责任编辑:admin) |