(11)Peter N.Steams,"Social History and History:A Progress Report," Journal of Social History,Vol.19,No.2(Winter,1985),pp.319-334; Peter N.Steams,"Social History Present and Future," Journal of Social History,Vol.37,No.1,Special Issue(Autumn,2003),pp.9-19. (12)Lynn Hunt,ed.,The New Cultural History,Berkeley:University of California Press,1989; Victoria E.Bonnell,and Lynn Hunt,eds.,Beyond the Cultural Turn:New Directions in the Study of Society and Culture,Berkeley:University of California Press,1999; Lawrence B.Glickman,"The 'Cultural Turn'," in Eric Foner,and Lisa McGirr,eds.,American History Now,Philadelphia:Temple University Press,2011,pp.221-241. (13)关于“硬”问题(如市场、人口、物价、工资等)和“软”问题(如权力的效果、道德、认知、价值、记忆、情绪等)的说法,来自Florencia E.Mallon,"Time on the Wheel:Cycles of Revisionism and the 'New Cultural History'," The Hispanic American Historical Review,Vol.79,No.2(May,1999),p.334。 (14)参见[美]乔伊斯、阿普尔比、林恩·亨特、玛格丽特·雅各布著,刘北成、薛绚译:《历史的真相》,上海人民出版社2011年版,第172-201、209-233页。 (15)Samuel P.Hays,"Society and Polities:Politics and Society," The Journal of Interdisciplinary History,Vol.15,No.3(Winter,1985),pp.481-482. (16)Graham,"The Stunted Career of Policy History," p.30. (17)Cordon Craig,"Political History," Daedalus,Vol.100,No.2(Spring,1971),p.323. (18)William E.Leuchtenburg,"The Pertinence of Political History:Reflections on the Significance of the State in America," The Journal of American History,Vol.73,No.3(Dec.,1986),p.585. (19)J.Morgan Kousser,"Toward 'Total Political History':A Rational-Choice Research Program," The Journal of Interdisciplinary History,Vol.20,No.4(Spring,1990),p.521. (20)美国学者罗纳德·佛米萨诺指出,当社会史势头正盛的时期,史家普遍看重“政治的社会基础”;在新文化史蔚然成风以后,许多史家转而强调“政治文化”。社会史和文化史对政治的塑造性影响,于此可见一斑。参见Ronald P.Formisano,"The Concept of Political Culture," The Journal of Interdisciplinary History,Vol.31,No.3(Winter,2001),pp.393-426,重点参见第395页。在近期的中国史学界也出现了类似苗头。参见赵世瑜:《社会史研究向何处去》,《河北学刊》,2005年第1期,第62-70页。 (21)J.Morgan Kousser,"Restoring Politics to Political History," The Journal of Interdisciplinary History,Vol.12,No.4(Spring,1982),p.569. (22)Lynn Hunt,Politics,Culture,and Class in the French Revolution,Berkeley:University of California Press,2004;[美]林·亨特著,郑明萱、陈瑛译:《法国革命时期的家庭罗曼史》,商务印书馆2008年版;林·亨特著,沈占春译:《人权的发明:一部历史》,商务印书馆2011年版。 (23)Gordon Wood,The Purpose of the Past:Reflections on the Use the History,New York:The Penguin Press,2008,pp.2-5,8-12. (24)Mark H.Left,"Revisioning U.S.Political History," The American Historical Review,Vol.100,No.3(Jun.,1995),p.829. (25)美国历史学家迈克尔·朱克曼在谈到研究殖民地时期的优势时说,这时没有国家,也没有总统,因此可以不必管国家政治,也不必同总统打交道,甚至可以让政治出局。迈克尔·朱克曼:《美国早期史在中国:现实中的往昔》,《史学月刊》,2008年第2期,第18页。 (26)Craig,"Political History," pp.323-324. (27) Leuchtenburg,"The Pertinence of Political History," p.586. (28)Left,"Revisioning U.S.Political History," p.834. (29)[法]弗朗索瓦·多斯著,马胜利译:《碎片化的历史学:从〈年鉴〉到‘新史学’》,北京大学出版社2008年版,第40、47页。
(责任编辑:admin) |