(112)Beer,Benson,et al.,"New Trends in History," p.897. (113)Elizabeth Fox-Genovese and Eugene D.Genovese,"The Political Crisis of Social History:A Marxian Perspective," Journal of Social History,Vol.10,No.2(Winter,1976),p.217. (114)Eley,and Nield,"Why Does Social History Ignore Politics?" p.268. (115)Rebecca Edwards,"Politics as Social History:Political Cartoons in the Gilded Age," OAH Magazine of History,Vol.13,No.4(Summer,1999),p.11. (116)Leuchtenburg,"The Pertinence of Political History," pp.587-588. (117)Stearns,"Social and Political History," pp.3-5. (118)Kessler-Harris,"Social History," p.249. (119)中国社会史初步发达的时期,政治的缺失以及社会史如何处理同政治史的关系等问题,也引起了关注。参见赵世瑜:《社会史研究向何处去》,《河北学刊》,2005年第1期,第66-68页。 (120)Alon Confino,"Collective Memory and Cultural History:Problems of Method," American Historical Review,Vol.102,No.5(Dec.,1997),p.1395. (121)Elizabeth McKillen,"Introduction:Workers,Labor,and War:New Directions in the History of American Foreign Relations," Diplomatic History,Vol.34,No.4(September,2010),pp.641-642. (122) Craig,"Political History," p.325. (123)[荷兰]F.R.安克斯密特著,周建漳译:《历史表现》,北京大学出版社2011年版,第282、287页。 (124)Le Goff,"Is Politics Still the Backbone of History?" p.13. (125)Kousser,"Restoring Politics to Political History," pp.569-595; Paul F.Bourke and Donald A.DeBars,"Restoring Politics to PoliticalHistory," The Journal of Interdisciplinary History,Vol.15,No.3(Winter,1985),pp.459-466. (126)J.Morgan Kousser,"Are Political Acts Unnatural?" The Journal of Interdisciplinary History,Vol.15,No.3(Winter,1985),p.468. (127)Kousser,"Are Political Acts Unnatural?" p.479. (128)Scan Wilentz,The Rise of American Democracy:Jefferson to Lincoln,New York:W.W.Norton,2005,p.xx. (129)Jacob,et al.,eds.,The Democratic Experiment,pp.6,8. (130)法国史学界的情况可以作为佐证。虽然复兴的政治史“在视野和方法上已打上了年鉴学派的深刻烙印”,但它并不仅只是对年鉴学派的借鉴与模仿,而是极力强调和坚持政治的自主性。例如,勒内·雷蒙就强烈反对年鉴学派的唯物史观,反对把社会经济史凌驾于政治史之上。参见吕一民、乐启良:《政治的回归》,《浙江学刊》,2011年第4期,第126页。 (131)See Bruce Levine,"The History of Politics and the Politics of History," International Labor and Working-Class History,No.46(Fall,1994),p.60. (132)吕一民、乐启良:《政治的回归》,《浙江学刊》,2011年第4期,第127页。 (133)Wilentz,"American Political Histories," p.23.
(责任编辑:admin) |